BALLPARK ADVENTURES
  • Home
  • Ballpark Reviews
    • MLB >
      • Guaranteed Rate Field (Chicago White Sox)
      • Sun Trust Park (Atlanta Braves)
      • Wrigley Field (Chicago Cubs)
    • MiLB Triple-A >
      • BB&T Ballpark (Charlotte Knights)
      • Coolray Field (Gwinnett Braves)
      • Durham Bulls Athletic Park (Durham Bulls)
      • First Tennessee Park (Nashville Sounds )
      • Harbor Park (Norfolk Tides)
      • Huntington Park (Columbus Clippers)
      • Victory Field (Indianapolis Indians)
    • MiLB Double-A >
      • Smokies Stadium (Tennessee Smokies)
      • The Diamond (Richmond Flying Squirrels)
    • MiLB Advanced-A >
      • BB&T Ballpark (Winston-Salem Dash)
      • Five County Stadium (Carolina Mudcats)
      • Haley Toyota Field (Salem Red Sox)
      • Segra Stadium (Fayetteville Woodpeckers) >
        • Jim Perry Stadium (Buies Creek Astros)
      • TicketReturn.com Field (Myrtle Beach Pelicans)
    • MiLB Single-A >
      • First National Bank Field (Greensboro Grasshoppers)
      • Fluor Field (Greenville Drive)
      • Intimidators Stadium (Kannapolis Intimidators)
      • Joseph P. Riley Jr. Park (Charleston Riverdogs)
      • L.P. Frans Stadium (Hickory Crawdads)
      • McCormick Field (Asheville Tourists)
      • Modern Woodmen Park (Quad Cities River Bandits)
      • Spirit Communications Park (Columbia Fireflies)
      • SRP Park (Augusta GreenJackets)
      • Whitaker Bank Park (Lexington Legends)
    • MiLB Rookie >
      • Joe O'Brien Field (Elizabethton Twins)
      • Hunter Wright Stadium (Kingsport Mets)
      • Pioneer Park (Greeneville Astros)
      • TVA Credit Union Ballpark (Johnson City Cardinals)
    • Independent >
      • BB&T Point (High Point Rockers)
  • Our Adventures
  • Ballpark Timeline
    • 2019 Ballparks
    • 2018 Ballparks
    • 2017 Ballparks
  • Contact
  • Home
  • Ballpark Reviews
    • MLB >
      • Guaranteed Rate Field (Chicago White Sox)
      • Sun Trust Park (Atlanta Braves)
      • Wrigley Field (Chicago Cubs)
    • MiLB Triple-A >
      • BB&T Ballpark (Charlotte Knights)
      • Coolray Field (Gwinnett Braves)
      • Durham Bulls Athletic Park (Durham Bulls)
      • First Tennessee Park (Nashville Sounds )
      • Harbor Park (Norfolk Tides)
      • Huntington Park (Columbus Clippers)
      • Victory Field (Indianapolis Indians)
    • MiLB Double-A >
      • Smokies Stadium (Tennessee Smokies)
      • The Diamond (Richmond Flying Squirrels)
    • MiLB Advanced-A >
      • BB&T Ballpark (Winston-Salem Dash)
      • Five County Stadium (Carolina Mudcats)
      • Haley Toyota Field (Salem Red Sox)
      • Segra Stadium (Fayetteville Woodpeckers) >
        • Jim Perry Stadium (Buies Creek Astros)
      • TicketReturn.com Field (Myrtle Beach Pelicans)
    • MiLB Single-A >
      • First National Bank Field (Greensboro Grasshoppers)
      • Fluor Field (Greenville Drive)
      • Intimidators Stadium (Kannapolis Intimidators)
      • Joseph P. Riley Jr. Park (Charleston Riverdogs)
      • L.P. Frans Stadium (Hickory Crawdads)
      • McCormick Field (Asheville Tourists)
      • Modern Woodmen Park (Quad Cities River Bandits)
      • Spirit Communications Park (Columbia Fireflies)
      • SRP Park (Augusta GreenJackets)
      • Whitaker Bank Park (Lexington Legends)
    • MiLB Rookie >
      • Joe O'Brien Field (Elizabethton Twins)
      • Hunter Wright Stadium (Kingsport Mets)
      • Pioneer Park (Greeneville Astros)
      • TVA Credit Union Ballpark (Johnson City Cardinals)
    • Independent >
      • BB&T Point (High Point Rockers)
  • Our Adventures
  • Ballpark Timeline
    • 2019 Ballparks
    • 2018 Ballparks
    • 2017 Ballparks
  • Contact
Search by typing & pressing enter

YOUR CART

OUR ADVENTURES

11/10/2017 0 Comments

Jim Edmonds: Hall of Famer

BY: MATTHEW PRESLAR

Picture
I’m not here to present a new earth shattering idea, but more to present my thoughts on why the great baseball player, Jim Edmonds, deserves a spot in Cooperstown. When evaluating any player for Hall Of Fame status, one should look at numbers of inducted players during a relatively similar point in history. In many people’s opinions, Edmonds passes the eye test. Anybody watching Edmonds, especially during his Angels and Cardinals days, knew they had the opportunity to see an all time great catch every time he stepped in Center Field. If you searched YouTube for great catches to this day, you’ll see multiple versions of Edmonds on a dead sprint straight back and making a diving, full extension catch nearly against the Center Field wall. Those defensive plays alone warrant Hall of Fame consideration. However, Jim’s offensive numbers relative to the position and era also make him worthy. To aid my argument, I want to compare Edmonds’s production to Hall of Farmers Andre Dawson and Kirby Puckett. ​

Picture
ANDRE DAWSON
HOMERUNS  438 
BATTING AVERAGE  .279
RBIs  1591
RUNS  1373
SB  314
OBP  .323
SLG  .482
GOLD GLOVES  8
GAMES PLAYED 2627 
*1993-94 with Boston, primarily as DH
Picture
KIRBY PUCKETT
HOMERUNS  207 
BATTING AVERAGE  .318
RBIs  1080
RUNS  1071
SB  134
OBP  .360
SLG  .477
GOLD GLOVES  6
GAMES PLAYED 1783
*1987 & 1991 World Series Champion
Picture
JIM EDMONDS
HOMERUNS  393 
BATTING AVERAGE  .284
RBIs  1199
RUNS  1251
SB  67
OBP  .376
SLG  .527
GOLD GLOVES  6
GAMES PLAYED 2011 
*2006 World Series Champion

When making my comparisons, I take a traditional look at a player. I don’t get into the modern numbers such as WAR (wins above replacement), but I focus on the basic statistics. From relatively similar areas, Edmonds is on par with these two Hall of Fame players. As these statistics suggest, he is an offensive blend of these two great players. His career average is five points higher that Dawson, with also a better OBP% and SLG%. In four seasons worth of fewer games played, Edmonds is slightly behind in Home Runs, RBI and runs scored. Also of note, Dawson padded stats by playing two seasons with the Red Sox where he could get additional at bats as a DH. In comparison, Edmonds had a World Series championship with the Cardinals, while Dawson never won a title.

In comparison to Kirby Puckett, Edmonds has nearly double his home runs and had an advantage in slugging percentage by fifty points. In terms of being a “table setter,” Puckett had a much better batting average. However, Edmonds surprisingly had a better on base percentage and more runs scored. Both players equal in winning six gold gloves a piece. Both players also are World Series Champions.

​By the numbers alone, Edmonds is as worthy of induction as either of these relative contemporaries. His power numbers and overall run production rival Dawson in far few games played. He won the same amount of Gold Glove awards as Puckett. He is a World Champion. It is a great travesty that he received a disrespectful 2.5% of the vote and was subsequently dropped from the ballot. For anybody that loved Cardinals baseball in the early to mid 2000’s, or anybody that likes great defense in Center Field, Jim Edmonds is Hall of Fame in your mind. 
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    VIEW ALL POSTS
    CONTACT US

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    August 2020
    May 2020
    December 2019
    October 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017

FOLLOW OUR ADVENTURES

OUR PURPOSE

Our Purpose is to show that going to a baseball game is the best value in entertainment. 
Baseball Makes Memories.

​BALLPARK ADVENTURES

Our Story
Ballpark Timeline
Reviews & Rating System
Collaborators Welcome
Contact Us​
© COPYRIGHT 2020
​ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
SITE DESIGN BY REBECCA PRESLAR